Hot Rod Forum : Hotrodders Bulletin Board

Hot Rod Forum : Hotrodders Bulletin Board (http://www.hotrodders.com/forum/)
-   Engine (http://www.hotrodders.com/forum/engine/)
-   -   Rebuilding top end (http://www.hotrodders.com/forum/rebuilding-top-end-225628.html)

crussell85 11-01-2012 01:17 PM

Rebuilding top end
 
I have a 2002 Impala with the 3.8 v6. The car has 298,xxx miles on it. Recently I've been losing antifreeze somewhere internally, I don't see it leaking externally. I was contemplating rebuilding the top end. When I told the guy at the machine shop what I wanted to do he said in his experience with that many miles after rebuilding the top end the piston rings like to come unseated and sometimes break due to the additional compression and the top end being more efficient. Does anyone agree with this? And is there any way to check if its just the intake gaskets giving me the problem without tearing it apart?

E.Furgal 11-01-2012 01:44 PM

yes, they are not lie'n to you..

the lower end with 300k on it, will now have like new top end, and will suck oil right passed the rings , the rings may not break.. but it won't matter.. it's smoke like a bas__rd..

BOBCRMAN@aol.com 11-01-2012 01:45 PM

Your machinest is full of S....T.

That is a lot of miles. But those engines are not hard on rings or valve train parts. Aside from pressure testing and milling the heads, HAS TO BE DONE.. A valve job/seal replace will help excessive oil usage. As long as coolant is kept out of the oiling system. I've seen the short blocks on these go many many miles. It's the intake/head gasket problems that kill these engines. Or in this area of the country the trans goes or the engine cradle rots out.

BogiesAnnex1 11-01-2012 03:15 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by crussell85 (Post 1605861)
I have a 2002 Impala with the 3.8 v6. The car has 298,xxx miles on it. Recently I've been losing antifreeze somewhere internally, I don't see it leaking externally. I was contemplating rebuilding the top end. When I told the guy at the machine shop what I wanted to do he said in his experience with that many miles after rebuilding the top end the piston rings like to come unseated and sometimes break due to the additional compression and the top end being more efficient. Does anyone agree with this? And is there any way to check if its just the intake gaskets giving me the problem without tearing it apart?

If it's leaking internally you should see it in the oil. A pressure test of the colling system is in order to see if the system is actually leaking, if it is it won't hold pressure. A 2002 would have DexCool, this stuff can and does attack gaskets as it ages and runs out of buffers.

Before tearing the heads off a leakdown test would give an idea as to how good the rings are assuming the valves hold pressure.

Too a general extent what you mechanic is saying is that when the top end is restored to an old engine with worn pistons, rings and cylinder walls that often the result of restored pumping actions above the piston will pull oil around the worn parts and will allow more blow by into the crankcase. This depends upon the wear on those parts. If the engine isn't an oil burner today chances are good you can do the top end without introdcing any new problems. If it passes a leakdown test I don't think I'd do anything but chase and repair the coolant leak. Today's engine valves have special treatments on them that refacing the seats take off, once removed their life span will be shortened and you'll be back into the engine again and again for repairs or replacements. So I'd be cautious about just fixing things that don't necessarily need fixing because we used to do these things as a matter of course a few years ago, much has changed in recent times.

Bogie

crussell85 11-01-2012 03:51 PM

I just changed my oil Sunday and let the oil sit in the drain pan overnight and didn't see any antifreeze/water in the pan. Can someone explain to me or give me a link of how to do a leak down test on the cooling system?

Plaintoast 11-01-2012 05:31 PM

I've heard this old wives tale for years. even had a shop owner ask me not to do "too" good of a job on a head rebuild citing that very reason.
i have not yet seen any evidence of it being true.
if you think about it, i can understand where that's coming from, but again, I've never seen any proof.

BogiesAnnex1 11-01-2012 06:03 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Plaintoast (Post 1605929)
I've heard this old wives tale for years. even had a shop owner ask me not to do "too" good of a job on a head rebuild citing that very reason.
i have not yet seen any evidence of it being true.
if you think about it, i can understand where that's coming from, but again, I've never seen any proof.

Way back when dinosaurs ruled the earth and I was going to college, I worked in an all night shop in San Luis Obispo. I drew a job one night to do a top end rebuild on a high mileage 55, 265 Chevy. When I got the heads off I could see the pistons moved about as much sideways as they would up and down. I told the foreman that the engine was shot and doing a top end would just make an oil burning, smoker even worse. He said to just get on with it which I did, buttoned it up early in the morning hours took it for a test drive. It left a thick cloud of oil smoke for several miles. I took it back and wrote up a report sheet that basically said rebuilding the top end only made its smoking habit worse. Next day it was gone. Day after that it was back in my stall with instructions to pull it apart and rebuild the bottom end. Did that with an overbore, new pistons and rings, new bearings, etc. Put the heads back on fired it up no smoke no oil consumption beyond what you'd expect for breaking in the rings.

Bogie

Plaintoast 11-01-2012 06:32 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by oldbogie (Post 1605935)
Way back when dinosaurs ruled the earth and I was going to college, I worked in an all night shop in San Luis Obispo. I drew a job one night to do a top end rebuild on a high mileage 55, 265 Chevy. When I got the heads off I could see the pistons moved about as much sideways as they would up and down. I told the foreman that the engine was shot and doing a top end would just make an oil burning, smoker even worse. He said to just get on with it which I did, buttoned it up early in the morning hours took it for a test drive. It left a thick cloud of oil smoke for several miles. I took it back and wrote up a report sheet that basically said rebuilding the top end only made its smoking habit worse. Next day it was gone. Day after that it was back in my stall with instructions to pull it apart and rebuild the bottom end. Did that with an overbore, new pistons and rings, new bearings, etc. Put the heads back on fired it up no smoke no oil consumption beyond what you'd expect for breaking in the rings.

Bogie

i wouldn't really consider that proof would you?
to me it sounded like the lower end was already bad. i think the op was referring to the top end rebuild causing the lower end to have problems.
or maybe i just misunderstood your post.

crussell85 11-01-2012 08:19 PM

Anyways, the engine runs great just have to keep adding coolant and not really sure where its going. I read somewhere about putting a balloon or rubber glove on the filler hole of the radiator and cranking the engine over and if the balloon blows up then you have combustion pressure going into the cooling system. This sounds kinda froggy, need citation? Bogie, could explain how to do the test you were talking about earlier?

BOBCRMAN@aol.com 11-01-2012 08:24 PM

The 3.8 engine was a GM wonder. They toyed with this motor, changed things for many years. Untill it started lasting too long. Then it was discontinued.

As stated they last many miles. Most are just getting broken in at two hundred thousand.. Most never see more than 3200 rpm. Cruise at under 2000 rpm. The only problems they have is intake plenums/gaskets and head gaskets. Usually at higher miles. This example probably spent a lot of time on I-75 and I-94 racking up the three hundred thou miles in comfort.

These are not 56 Chevrolet engines. They don't have fancy coatings on the valvetrain. It is just GM got it right, finally. Thin rings that don't beat up the ring lands, conform to the cylinders better. Light weight valves and springs. Positive oil controll seals. Fuel injection and OD tranny.

You will usually find the leak is on the back head. Drivers end. Between the coolant passage and the fire ring of the last cylinder. It Brinnells into the casting from heat cycling. Usually only leaks, into cylinder, at running temp at higher speeds.
You can have any auto repair place put a tester on the cooling system. You may be able to rent/borrow a tester from a chain auto store.

crussell85 11-01-2012 09:07 PM

Yes, the majority of miles were put on the car on the highway cruising at seventy five-eighty with the cruise set most of the time. Maybe I'll just pull into a shop and let them diagnose it. Even if they charge me an hour labor it could be worth it over chasing and hoping.

BogiesAnnex1 11-02-2012 11:59 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Plaintoast (Post 1605940)
i wouldn't really consider that proof would you?
to me it sounded like the lower end was already bad. i think the op was referring to the top end rebuild causing the lower end to have problems.
or maybe i just misunderstood your post.

No, not a cause; but rebuilding only the top end made a bad situation way worse. Now there was no ignoring the total situation it all had to be fixed or scrapped.

Bogie

crussell85 11-02-2012 04:15 PM

The engines not toast, it runs great, never have to add oil. The car has been really good to me. I took the car to a shop and he ended up tracking it down to some thermostat bypass elbow or something like that. So no internal leaks! Two bills later and a huge sigh of relief and I'll be back on the road with my trusty car, wouldn't trade it for a brand new one!

cdminter59 11-02-2012 04:47 PM

Rebuilding top end
 
Leaking intake manifold gaskets on these cars are common. Just replace the intake manifold gasket and flush the radiator and block. Do not use Dex-Cool antifreeze anymore. It is a fact that the Dex-Cool reacts with the material the intake gaskets are made with. Check out this website full of compliants. 2002 Chevrolet Impala Leaking Coolant, Intake Manifold Gasket Failure | CarComplaints.com

crussell85 11-02-2012 06:34 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by cdminter59 (Post 1606313)
Leaking intake manifold gaskets on these cars are common. Just replace the intake manifold gasket and flush the radiator and block. Do not use Dex-Cool antifreeze anymore. It is a fact that the Dex-Cool reacts with the material the intake gaskets are made with. Check out this website full of compliants. 2002 Chevrolet Impala Leaking Coolant, Intake Manifold Gasket Failure | CarComplaints.com

I don't want to tear into the engine and replace gaskets that are fine


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 12:49 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2017, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.
Search Engine Optimization by vBSEO 3.6.0 PL2
vBulletin Security provided by vBSecurity v2.2.2 (Pro) - vBulletin Mods & Addons Copyright © 2017 DragonByte Technologies Ltd.
Copyright Hotrodders.com 1999 - 2012. All Rights Reserved.