Henry, first off, yes thank you being the VERY first thing he needs to do is move the door around until it fits where he KNOWS it fit. And that is at the very top, he said that is original as he had spliced the quarter below that. When he put the quarter on the original door FIT up there at the top and was level with the quarter. So if he moves the door down far enough for that to fit, it looks like the door will hit the rocker at the bottom, it is THAT far off.
But getting the door down is key to start this, being it looks like the gap is pretty large at the bottom to rocker. But once that is done, you have a repro door skin against a repro quarter at those body lines......there is no way in hell you can tell WHICH is wrong at that point. Not without making a template off the other quarter if it's original to see what is wrong, the quarter or the door. A template can be made of the door too, the good door, then turn that template around and see what you have.