I'm wondeirng if your rings are stuck from lack of use and the gunk that has turned to varnish is locking them up. With a rich mixture it would be easy for fuel to just "wash" down the cylinders. Usually the crank case pressures will keep anything from entering the block through a cracked or missaligned intake manifold gasket. It typically goes the other way....oil into the intake tract. Hmmmm....on deeper thought I wonder if you have a cracked ring. Do a compression test and you will know real fast if the fuel is washing passed the pistons.
Last thought, a blown head gasket could allow cylinder gases to enter the crank case. I have personally had blown head gaskets leak into everything...coolent into the oil, oil into the coolent, gases into the crank case...just depends on the path of the leak.
I would think a leak down tester (pump up the cylinders and listen for where the "hiss" is) would pinpoint the crank case leak.
Good luck!