I have heard negative things about most all companies you mentioned, but I always take them with a grain of salt.
I just recently got a whole front end for my 50 Plymouth 2 dr wagon from Fatman. The parts are top notch, welding is very good, gussets where they should be and fit is right on. Of course when you fit, you always have some wiggle room for adjustments.
You didn't say what vehicle you are putting the parts on, but I do like the Fatman stuff and quality is very good.