Well, there are controversies in the harley world but not as much. Just before I started this '66 GTO project this past May I finished a Harley softail project. Took what was a stock '92 Heritage that I had rebuilt the top end with new heads, pistons and cam as well as carb. At that time I did a bunch of research and testing - including dyno testing - and ended up running D&D Fatcats (a 2-1 pipe). Great quality and great performance. That was more than a year ago.
But I took it much further last winter. Tore the bike down completely. Powder coated the frame. Chromed the rear swingarm. Put in a Jims 6 spd overdrive polished billet tranny. Performance Machine billet front/rear brakes. Spyke billet starter. Worked with R&R up in NH to build a 113" Evo hybrid. S&S case, crank, jugs. R&R billet heads, Super G carb, R&R custom grind cam, 11.2:1 w/forged custom pistons. All new tins including 5 gal fat bob tanks, repro bubble back bags - looks alot like a '58 DuoGlide. But runs close to 130lbs tq and 130hp on a DynoJet 250 - through my Bassani RoadRage 2-1 pipes.
Truth is that on a Harley V-twin, the more you deviate from the design of something like the Bassani Road Rage, the V&H PropPipe, or the D&D Fatcat 2-1's, the more your performance suffers. But this is a little different than the subject of this thread. Each of these pipes are essentially headers, and the 2-1 is the collector. The stepped header design is what makes it or breaks it.
The stock harley pipes especially on newer bikes combined with the fact that they're set to run REAL lean makes it so that moving to something like the street sweeper or the Fourbidden along with a powercommander or SERT is a real improvement, but most of that is because you're getting the air fuel a lot less lean and allowing the intake to open up a little. If you swapped pipes to a ProPipe or Road Rage, you'd be amazed at how much better it can be. If I put a set of sweepers on my bike and even retuned it, I promise you I'd lose at least 10hp and I'd make my torque curve a lot less flat. Doesn't mean they're bad pipes - or the 4bidden. Just that if you want to really optimize power, neither of them are real performance pipes. They have a cool look though.
Added: Specifically for the 4bidden, the 2 pipes per cylinder detracts from performance. You have only one round exhaust port per cylinder. A single round stepped pipe with equal lengths to the collecter is a more efficient and therefore power friendly design. It's probably not an issue for you at all - it's not a bad pipe. Kind of interesting.